Skip to content

Tough to take Pat Fitzgerald seriously

Nov 10, 2009, 11:30 AM EDT

The fruit has been hanging pretty low for Notre Dame detractors since the Irish unraveled last weekend. Low enough for Northwestern coach Pat Fitzgerald to take a shot at the Notre Dame program as well.

In his weekly “College Football Overtime” roundup, Sports Illustrated’s Stewart Mandel took advantage of the high-water mark wins for both Stanford and Northwestern and the low-water mark loss for the Irish, and postulated that the three programs really aren’t all that different. He even got this money quote out of Northwestern head coach Pat Fitzgerald.

“Even though we’re similar academically, we’re in a little different boat as Stanford and Notre Dame,” Fitzgerald said. “We’ve been consistently winning since 1995. They’re still saying they can do it, but we’re doing it.”

While Mandel was quick to get his jabs in about the Four Horsemen, Touchdown Jesus, and Rudy, he wasn’t too quick to look at the record books. It’s tough to take Fitzgerald seriously if he thinks a 3-8, 4-7, 3-9, 6-7, 4-8, and 6-6 seasons since 1995 can be considered consistent winners. Likewise, it’s tough to take Mandel, a Northwestern alum, seriously if he’s going to merely just sidestep pretty obvious facts.

It’s very likely that Fitzgerald was directing his blast toward Palo Alto and not to his next-door neighbor, but to compare this season’s Northwestern squad with either Notre Dame or Stanford is pretty difficult. Mandel states that all three teams have six victories and only Northwestern and Stanford have a victory over a Top 10 opponent, but let’s see which one of these teams doesn’t belong:

TEAM:               RECORD:     SCHEDULE STRENGTH

Stanford                6-3                15
Notre Dame          6-3                 26
Northwestern        6-4                103

For as embarrassing a loss as the Navy game is perceived to be, Northwestern lost to both Syracuse and Minnesota, won very ugly against one-win Miami of Ohio, and their signature win was against one of the all-time smoke-and-mirrors teams in Iowa after their starting quarterback went down and they turned the ball over four times.

The point of this isn’t to ridicule Northwestern, but to merely ridicule the idea that the two programs can now be linked together. Notre Dame is into “Year Three of the Weis hot-seat debate” precisely because these programs will never be linked together. While the Four Horsemen will never run again and there likely won’t be a Rudy sequence hitting the multiplex, there will never be a day where I can go to the Notre Dame website and buy four seats on the 35 yard line for next week’s game. (And no, I don’t count returned ticket allotments from visiting teams.)

The Irish have struggled since Lou Holtz departed, and they’ve done so for a variety of reasons, institutional arrogance among them. They’ve done plenty to sully the brand that was once the gold standard in college football.  

But for Mandel to compare these three programs, without pointing out that Northwestern hasn’t played a Top-70 schedule in the past three seasons, and Stanford hasn’t beaten Notre Dame in the past seven tries is disingenuous. Even if your only criteria is wins and losses, Northwestern sits at
88-85 since they began winning “consistently,” while Notre Dame is
108-73. Notre Dame shouldn’t be puffing its chest about this mediocre
stretch of football, but it’s a far cry from the three games above .500, especially considering the recent shift in scheduling philosophy for the Wildcats. 

I’m trying hard not to come down too hard on Mandel, one of my favorite college football writers out there. But if you try hard enough, you can find plenty of things that Weis and the Irish have failed to achieve. There is no need to manipulate the numbers.   

  1. liamg19 - Nov 10, 2009 at 11:59 AM

    Here, here.

  2. oak - Nov 10, 2009 at 12:02 PM

    THANK YOU!!!
    the only thing that kept me from writing Stewart Mandel and pointing this out was that I couldn’t figure out a place to get the records.
    By these standards ND has been winning consistently since the 70s, with one off year.

  3. Steve - Nov 10, 2009 at 12:31 PM

    Nice work Keith! By the way, how many BCS bowls have Stanford and Northwestern been to combined?

  4. Keith Arnold - Nov 10, 2009 at 1:06 PM

    Steve — I tried to work that into the table, but SCHEDULE STRENGTH is so long that it looked bad… Probably should’ve let function stand over style, but I think the point got across.

  5. Tom - Nov 10, 2009 at 2:03 PM

    Thank you for writing an item about the Irish without lambasting them. Yes, the Navy loss was horrible but it is apparent many of the columnist enjoy kicking them when they are down. It pains them to ever write a good word so after the Navy game theirplates are full. All too often many writers create controversies and then they will write about them. again reading your article made my day. Incidentally the Navy game was my 85th consecutive home game.

  6. Jason - Nov 10, 2009 at 3:14 PM

    keith, i read the stewie article on si.com…. thank you for putting into words my thoughts. I thought the article was a low-blow by Mandel. Typical sensational writing to get fans riled up and talking about your article.

  7. T-Bone - Nov 10, 2009 at 3:42 PM

    This garbage is typical of Mandel who never misses a chance to try to get in a shot on Notre Dame. As for Fitzgerald, he’s a bit of a knot head who wouldn’t be the head coach at Northwestern if Randy Walker didn’t have a heart attack.

  8. jim zmigrocki - Nov 10, 2009 at 9:41 PM

    several years ago my wife and I went to Ryan field to see Mich. State play Northwestern. It was october and I beieve it was Northwesterns second home game. It was a beautiful day and Ryan field was sold out. At the time our son was a student at Michigan State and we got our tickets through our son. It was a great game and with three minutes left in the first half, I went to get my wife and I a hot dog. There were very few refreshment stands at Ryan field so I got in line. When my turn came I ordered three hot dogs and two cokes. I was amazed when the sales clerk told me that they were out of hot dogs. My comment was “This is why Northwestern will never play in a BCS game and will be a perrenial door mat in the big ten.” I’ve been to Notre Dame and most of the big ten schools for football games and I can honestly say the most pathetic place to watch a college football game is Ryan field, and I haven’t addressed the parking which is a aseparate nightmare. Obviously Mr. Mandel has never attended a Notre Dame, Northwestern or big ten football game….I bet he writes his drivel while channel surfing college football on his TV.

  9. Jennifer Deane - Nov 11, 2009 at 12:15 AM

    Keep telling it like it is, Keith. And consider doing it in ALL CAPS! Good work!

  10. Watch Free Movies Online - Jan 2, 2010 at 8:55 AM

    This page wasnt working earlier i tried accesing it but it timed out 4-5 times now i can access it. Why Does this happen? Am i the only one having this issue?

  11. billiga webbhotell - Jan 22, 2010 at 12:48 PM

    Wow…. I really enjoyed reading this article……… I m very impressed with your work. One thing I can say is that this blog is one of the best I’ve read till date…….. Keep up the good workk.

  12. free online movies to watch now - Jan 26, 2010 at 12:32 PM

    Hey, I just wanted to say what a fantastic website. I totally enjoyed it and found it fascinating reading. Excited to read your next post!

  13. Hey - Jan 31, 2010 at 9:31 PM

    Hey there, when browsing at your site i see some sort of weird codes all over the page, in case it’s important I just thought I’d let you know it says this with all sorts of other stuff after it: “Warning: Cannot modify header information – headers already sent in wp-settings.php line 12″

  14. Collen Panama - Feb 2, 2010 at 2:36 PM

    I trust you would not have reservations if I placed a part of this on my univeristy blog?

  15. free movie streams - Feb 5, 2010 at 9:09 AM

    Hey, I just wanted to say what a good website. I really enjoyed it and found it interesting reading. Excited to read your next post!

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!