The end is here.
Even with the usual heroics from Golden Tate, Jimmy Clausen, and Michael Floyd, a punishing performance by Robert Hughes, and 448 yards of offense, the Irish lose to Stanford. Like many teams before them, the Irish failed to contain Toby Gerhart, who ran for 205 yards on 29 carries for three touchdowns, even adding a touchdown pass of his own.
Even when Jack Swarbrick did his best to refute speculation this evening, reports are coming fast and furious that a decision has already been made on Charlie Weis’ future. ProFootballTalk’s Mike Florio reports that Weis has already cleaned out his office and the next few days will be full or rumors, speculation and hearsay, as reporters race to confirm the official ouster of Charlie Weis.
Here’s what we learned tonight:
1) Notre Dame’s defense cost the Irish this season.
When Robert Hughes was stuffed on a 3rd and short, you could feel the game slipping away from the Irish. The second half started to feel like a tennis match between two power servers, and when the Cardinal broke the Irish offense’s serve, it was a foregone conclusion that Stanford was going to score.
You don’t need stats to back up an argument that Notre Dame’s defense was terrible this season. They struggled in every segment of the game, a toxic mix of an inability to get pressure with down linemen and linebackers unable to stuff the run. Notre Dame’s secondary missed David Bruton’s ball-hawking presence, and for all the credit Kyle McCarthy deserved got this season, he’s a poor Cover 2 safety.
As I mentioned a few weeks ago, Weis’ demise was his inability to recruit front seven players early. The heralded recruiting class of 2006 had zero impact players, and Notre Dame seemed to stockpile tweener defensive ends in hopes that they’d become Justin Tuck. Morrice Richardson, Kerry Neal and Kallen Wade never developed, and players like John Ryan never became more than marginal reserves.
Weis’ inability to find a suitable defensive coordinator will be the number one reason why he loses his job, and his gamble to bring in Jon Tenuta, a well-respected defensive coach was the one that likely cost him the most. It would’ve been interesting to see what this Notre Dame defense would’ve looked like in a 3-4 base, utilizing the plethora of edge-type players that Notre Dame seems to have, and also giving the defense a better chance to hide their blitzes, something the Irish never did very well this season.
2) Golden Tate is a transcendent player.
Tate went for 205 yards tonight, pushing his receiving yards to an even 1,500 for the season on 93 catches. He’s scored 14 touchdowns in the final 8 games. Those are MONSTER numbers. People that fancy themselves technicians are eager to pick on Tate for some inexact routes and a few head scratching decisions, but why can’t we all just appreciate the incredible season that #23 has had? I understand that the Heisman has now become college football’s version of the MVP, but what does a .500 record have to do with a player’s greatness?
Tonight, ESPN’s announcing team was hellbent on recognizing Toby Gerhart as a legitimate Heisman contender, yet never seemed to mention the wide receiver that matched Gerhart’s numbers on the opposite sideline, doing it in a fraction of the touches from a position that’s much harder to make an impact. In a season where no single player stood alone, I’ve got no idea why Golden Tate isn’t getting more respect from the national media, even if it’s for a .500 team. If Notre Dame pulled that game out tonight, what’s the difference between a five loss Stanford squad and a five loss Notre Dame team?
3) Jack Swarbrick will certainly earn his salary this week.
A friend of mine with very good sources heard from two people in positions to know that both Bob Stoops and Brian Kelly were done deals. That two people with connections deep inside Notre Dame’s athletic department had such conflicting news goes to show you that Swarbrick is truly the man pulling the strings in the athletic department.
We can only take Swarbrick at his word that no decision has been made and no coach has been contacted, but I’d be shocked if a new coach isn’t announced within the week if Weis is out as head coach. The differences between Swarbrick and his predecessor Kevin White are startling, and Notre Dame fans should feel good about the man in charge of the university’s athletics.
4) The Irish football program is at a tipping point.
The decisions that will be made in the coming weeks will determine the fate of the Notre Dame football program. If Charlie Weis is fired, Jimmy Clausen is as good as gone. If Clausen goes, Golden Tate likely follows. Even with weapons like Michael Floyd, Kyle Rudolph, and Armando Allen, the Notre Dame program could look vastly different with a new coach roaming the sidelines. Add to that equation that the new coach will be running spring practice without Dayne Crist and no true backup quarterback, and spring installation will likely be limited as well.
Nobody knows for sure the thought process of Clausen or Tate, but they’re two players that are fiercely loyal to Charlie Weis. No player is bigger than a football program, especially one as storied as Notre Dame, but the decisions made off the field in the coming weeks, could greatly determine what happens for the next few seasons.
5) Charlie Weis is a great ambassador for Notre Dame.
Whether he’s the coach of Notre Dame’s football program for another season or another week, Charlie Weis was a true ambassador to the school. As Jack Swarbrick mentioned during his interview with the New York Times, the difference between perception and reality for Weis is stark. No coach has taken a larger beating these past few seasons than Weis, and it’s a puzzling dichotomy that has turned Weis into such a polarizing figure.
Watching ESPN’s GameDay this morning, I was touched by the story of Pete Carroll and young Jake Olson. It’s an uplifting story that shows us how important college football is to many of us, and how important Carroll and the Trojans are to a boy fighting insurmountable odds.
After watching that story, I was immediately reminded of a conversation I had in the press box during the USC game. I chatted with a national reporter that had covered college football for years. Her image of Charlie Weis and Pete Carroll, two coaches that both do incredible work in the community outside of football, was so divergent.
I can’t help but think that Notre Dame needs to do a better job letting people see the true head coach. With a school that so obviously understands branding and tradition, they failed Weis for five seasons, allowing him to be a punching bag in both the mainstream media and blogosphere, and rarely letting people get a glimpse of the great humanitarian that has run the football program the right way.
Just looking at the media relations team that USC has put together around Pete Carroll — whether it’s his official website, the cutting edge Heisman campaigns for Matt Leinart and Reggie Bush, or the incredibly visible work Carroll does with “A Better LA” and his other charitable work, USC has created an image that promotes its coach and his beliefs.
While Notre Dame has made great strides in the past few years and the Sports Information department is filled with true professionals, they’ve struggled to fight a very real battle with negativity that’s b
eing waged in the media, on
the recruiting path, and in the collective psyches’ of college football fans. Whether you want to believe it or not, that negativity is a large reason why the football program is on shaky ground.
If Charlie Weis loses his job this week, he surely has these last three seasons of mediocre football to blame. But if Notre Dame ever wants to truly win again, it’ll need to be as proactive protecting and managing its head coach as it is with its heralded tradition.
-
- Teo - Nov 30, 2009 at 2:41 PM
-
And, so the end is here, fans.
I have to express a word of thanks to Charlie Weis. When he arrived, we’d been in rough shape under Willingham and Davie (not to mention George O’Leary). It seemed almost impossible to have a game in which we competed against a quality opponent. Charlie changed that. Unfortunately, it’s too often that we lose close games.
Having said this, our new coach has a pretty good foundation. Everyone believes JC will leave early. Notre Dame really doesn’t have a history of players leaving early. So, we’ll see how it goes. My own hope is that Jimmy comes back and plays for someone like Brian Kelly, Kirk Ferentz or Bob Stoops. We’ll see how it goes.
One further remark: Bobby Bowden may be resigning today. If he does, Notre Dame’s search for a replacement just got a lot tougher.
-
- mrrandolph - Nov 30, 2009 at 2:51 PM
-
It is easy to blame the defense for this year’s shortcomings but Charlie is responsible for everyone on the squad. Coaches and players whether they are hired or recruited are at ND because he wants them there. Don’t you get it? He is responsible.
And, Urban, like many coaches, coach to their personnel.Alex Smith and Chris Leak were not exactly spread option QBs.
Let’s see here are my top four excuses
2007- Ty left the cubbard bare.
2008- we are too young
2009-it is the defenses fault
2010-CW or Jimmy and Golden are gone, or academic standards are too high
2011 – Jimmy and Golden left
-
- StephenOfTroy - Nov 30, 2009 at 4:48 PM
-
grandpa, Robert T. Gilleran doesn’t “have the interest of ND or college football at heart.” Didn’t you read where he said ND has “zero future” without Charlie Weis?
You may have noticed, as I did, that in his latest blast of nonsense, he starts out by saying Swarbrick and Jenkins don’t really have any power and instead it’s some shadow group of former student-athletes, but then he abruptly says “well back to work on the real world civil rico cases….” Uh, sure, robbie. Go get ‘em, tiger!
Looks to me like Robert T. Gilleran has given up trying to sell us on his Theory O’ College Football and is back to trying to sell us shares in his RICO tax shelter. But that’s part of what got him disbarred. So tread carefully, grandpa. Investments can lose value, particularly where said investments are never actually created and your soon-to-be-disbarred attorney lies to you about creating them.
-
- StephenOfTroy - Nov 30, 2009 at 6:30 PM
-
Kejji, bak, and, yes, even Keith Arnold: Did you catch Pardon the Interruption today? Both Kornheiser and Wilbon agreed that Neuheisel COMPLETELY deserved to get that deep TD pass thrown against him after he called that time-out. In fact Wilbon said Pete Carroll should have done an onside-kick after scoring the TD. Wilbon said Neuseisel had it coming after talking all that noise and taking out ads in the paper (“the football monopoly is officially over”).
Couldn’t agree more. FIGHT ON, TROJANS!
-
- StephenOfTroy - Nov 30, 2009 at 6:43 PM
-
Keith Arnold, I ALSO stand by my comment about the soft schedule the Irish play.
TODAY, none other than Lou Holtz said that Notre Dame plays “one top-20 team a year, two at the most.” He made that comment in the context of saying that there’s no excuse for not winning at ND. As usual, I agree with Coach Holtz.
So yes, Golden Tate looks good. Lots of players would, if they played against crummy teams who themselves are going into prevent defenses in many 4th quarters because they have a big lead.
-
- Kejji - Dec 1, 2009 at 1:17 AM
-
Didn’t catch pardon….but heard Jim Rome say Neuheisel got the smack down he deserved…heck, even UCLA linebacker Reggie Carter said “How mad could you be? we called a timeout; we kept the game going, so obviously we wanted to keep playing, we obviously didn’t play hard enough”.
-
- grandpashyena - Dec 1, 2009 at 10:17 AM
-
I just picture him sitting in a small, dark, shabby room with a bare bulb over an old HP 386 computer typing away his blows against the empire. He wonders why the world ( ND especially) has not taken his ranting as gospel and done all he wishes. The voices are getting louder,the deamons are getting closer. All is lost.
-
- StephenOfTroy - Dec 1, 2009 at 7:05 PM
-
thanks for the tip, Kejji. I will try to find Rome on YouTube. He reminds me of Rain Man, the way he sometimes repeats what he says about four times. But when he’s on, he’s ON. And it sounds like Reggie Carter is an honest man.
I wish our season had gone better, but anytime you beat ND in South Bend and embarrass UCLA, I count the season a success. I was just glad to see the defense play with some intensity again.
grandpa, now that Charlie Weis is out, Robert T. Gilleran has hung a sign over his motel room door (where he rents his room by the week) that says “Abandon Hope All Ye Who Enter Here.” But he left up the sign that says “Expert Shoe Repair and Civil RICO Case Analysis.”
-
- joshua becker - Dec 3, 2009 at 10:17 PM
-
When one views the issue at hand, i have to agree with your conclusions. You understandably show knowledge about this topic and i have much to learn after reading your post.Many salutations and i will come back for any further updates.
-
- Search engine placement specialist - Dec 5, 2009 at 10:16 PM
-
I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and have my children check up here often. I am quite sure they will learn lots of new stuff here than anybody else!
-
- linux virus - Dec 13, 2009 at 2:39 PM
-
This is absolutely fantastic! Thankyou for making this available!!!
-
- Free Backlinks - Dec 17, 2009 at 4:35 PM
-
Doing some web surfing and noticed your blog looks a bit screwed up in my K-meleon browser. But fortunately hardly anybody uses it anymore but you may want to check it out.
-
- causes of bad breath - Dec 19, 2009 at 5:16 PM
-
Hello, just needed you to know I have added your site to my Google bookmarks because of your great blog layout. But seriously, I think your site has one of the freshest theme I’ve came across. It really helps make reading your blog a lot better.
-
- the day the earth stood still - Dec 30, 2009 at 6:49 PM
-
What’s happend? I have to keep Refreshing the page to even be able to view the post can someone fix this issue please?
-
- Watch Big Bang Theory Online - Jan 10, 2010 at 8:42 AM
-
Can’t wait until the next episode, need my Big Bang Theory fix!
-
- Aimbot Download - Jan 19, 2010 at 12:19 PM
-
A well written article, i’ve bookmarked it so I can keep it for reference.
Thanks for writing it!
-
- Valentina Willmes - Jan 25, 2010 at 8:08 PM
-
Keep ‘em coming… you all do such a great job at such Concepts… can’t tell you how much I, for one appreciate all you do!
-
- Stihl Backpack Blower - Jan 31, 2010 at 12:04 AM
-
I would like to thank you for the endeavors you have made in publishing this article. I am trusting the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your fanciful writing abilities has inspired me to start my own blog now. Genuinely the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a fine example of it.
-
- Queen Air Mattress - Jan 31, 2010 at 4:23 PM
-
I really enjoy reading the articles on this blog. I’ll bookmark this so I can read more later.
-
- Slyvia Cristofori - Jan 31, 2010 at 9:46 PM
-
Thanks for this interesting post in fact you did me a great favor by providing me with this great information, that’s exactly what i was looking for you saved me a lot of searching time, by the way you are really good at making good informative posts in this area
.
-
- Hey - Feb 1, 2010 at 12:41 AM
-
Hi , when viewing at your blog i see some sort of weird codes all over the page, in case it’s important I just thought I’d let you know it says this with all sorts of other stuff after it: “Warning: Cannot modify header information – headers already sent in wp-settings.php line 12″
-
- love calculator - Feb 1, 2010 at 2:32 PM
-
Hey, I discovered your internet site when I was reading up on tennis. It is an absolutely great game but it takes so much practice to get descent at. Fed is my favourite tennis player after his win yesterday. Keep up the great work.
-
- SHOES LIFTS - Feb 1, 2010 at 6:52 PM
-
Shoe inserts are wedge-shaped inserts that fit in the heel part of a shoe, with the intention of adding lift under one or both feet for therapeutic reasons. Those who suffer foot pain when wearing shoes for an extended time. Shoe lifts can reduce suffering. Heel lifts are also perfect for people who need to increase their height.
-
- professional screen printing - Feb 1, 2010 at 8:57 PM
-
This blog definitely gave me some info I can use, thanks!
-
- Sherron Roscorla - Feb 3, 2010 at 9:12 AM
-
Hello, super post, I really enjoyed reading it. the article gave me the momentum to try my own blog, please check my article by clicking my name at the top of this article, Many thanks
