Feb 4, 2010, 2:00 PM EST
There will be plenty of time to breakdown the recruiting class. (My two word analysis: Good Start.) But first let’s start with some interesting tidbits from Brian Kelly’s press conference yesterday.
Most of you that have read this blog since it got started before last season, know that I’ve been incredibly underwhelmed by our defensive ends. Notre Dame hasn’t had a great edge rusher since Justin Tuck left Notre Dame with a year of eligibility left on the table. And while the Irish are switching to a 3-4 alignment, which many would think minimizes the necessity for great rush end play, Kelly’s made it clear he’ll be targeting and intent on upgrading the defensive end position.
“Our scholarship allotment is really going to have to look towards the
defensive end position. We feel like we’re set inside,” Kelly said. “There’s a number
of players that are going to be able to help us on the inside. We’ve got to get bigger and stronger on the edge of our defense, more
athletic on the edge of our defense. I think those are two absolutely
crucial needs for us moving forward after this class.”
It’s interesting to hear that Kelly thinks the inside guys are set. I’m going to toss out Ethan Johnson from the inside conversation, as its been clear that he’s not physically ready to play in the interior. So that leaves Ian Williams as the presumptive starter, with Sean Cwynar, Brandon Newman, Tyler Stockton, and Louis Nix to fill the rotation. That’s a lot of depth for one true tackle position. But it’s interesting to break down the defensive players and realize how physically undermanned the Irish are, especially after listening to Kelly’s qualifications.
“On the three-four they’ve got to be able to take on the guard and the
tackle. They have to have leverage and length,” Kelly said. “They can’t be 6’1″,
6’2″. They generally have to be in the 6’4″ range. They have to be
strong enough to take on. You saw the tackles that we have, the Matt
James and Tate’s, they’re 290, 300 pounds. So that guy’s got to be long, and he’s got to be solid. So that
profile, 6’4″, or plus, 250 pounds, they’re tough to come by. Those
guys are ones that you have to spend time recruiting.”
A quick breakdown of the Irish defense shows how inadequate the Irish physically match-up to Kelly’s ideal, which also might explain the fatal flaw of Charlie Weis’ defense. Including this year’s recruits, here’s a quick look at the size of defensive front-seven players that come close to fitting the ideal mold.
6’3″ 6’4″ 6’5″ 6’6″
Dan Fox Sean Cwynar* Bruce Heggie
Brian Smith Steve Filer
Louis Nix* Ethan Johnson*
Justin Utupo Kapron Lewis-Moore
Kendall Moore Emeka Nwankwo
*Listed as Defensive Tackles
If you take out guys that profile as defensive tackles, you’d have to eliminate Nix, Cwynar, and possibly Ethan Johnson, though I think he’s better served playing on an edge. That leaves your ideally sized defensive ends as Kapron Lewis-Moore, possibly Johnson, with Emeka Nwankwo as the only three guys that profile even close to being thick enough to play defensive end. As for edge linebackers in the 3-4, you’ve got to think Steve Filer profiles perfectly for Kelly and Bob Diaco’s system, and possibly Brian Smith, though the Irish will have to transition someone will edge ability, but mediocre size in the 6-foot-1 Darius Fleming either inside or into a hybrid role, not to mention fitting Manti Te’o into the middle of the 3-4.
Just like Charlie Weis, Kelly is also best known for his offensive prowess. Yet it’s interesting to note that 19 years of head coaching experience on the collegiate level allows you the confidence and know-how to take recruits like Schwenke and Heggie, two guys that would’ve never been on the previous coaching staff’s board. They are two guys that fit perfectly into the system Kelly is building defensively, and a big reason why a head coach has to have his hands in everything.