Dec 10, 2010, 3:41 PM EDT
After a week of nothing but good news for the Irish, Notre Dame finally didn’t get the commitment they were chasing when Iowa’s Christian French committed to Oregon over Notre Dame and his home state Hawkeyes yesterday. French is a freakish athlete, but where he’ll play and how effective he’ll be in college are still to be determined. The Irish were willing to give French his first look at wide receiver, but in the end French chose Chip Kelly’s Ducks, a decision you can hardly blame him for.
Looking for a silver lining? He was in South Bend yesterday when Brooklyn’s Ishaq Williams spent the day on his official visit, checking out campus with his father. Williams is looking at the Irish, and also visiting Syracuse and Penn State, with two other potential visits in the running before he makes his choice at the Army All-American bowl. Williams presents the Irish with the opportunity to land an elite athlete with tremendous size and speed at outside linebacker, a position where the Irish will need to replace both Kerry Neal and Brian Smith.
With 19 verbal commitments and a roster with not that many more openings, it appears the Irish are down to a select few targets in the 2011 recruiting class. We’ve already mentioned Williams. Let’s take a look at the big names still out there on the Irish big board.
TROY NIKLAS — DE: Niklas is one of those prototype defensive ends that Bob Diaco spoke of since Day One at Notre Dame. He’s 6-foot-6, a lean 245 pounds, and has the potential to grow into a monsterous 3-4 defensive end with great athleticism, as evidenced by an offer from Stanford to play tight end. Niklas would join a crowded front seven class of recruits and also gives Kelly the kind of pliable athlete that can play multiple positions depending on how he physically develops. At 6-6, he’s got the size to be a defensive end, tight end, or a mobile offensive tackle, three positions the Irish roster could use depth at.
SHANE RAY — DE/OLB: From the sounds of it, Ray is more of a hybrid defensive end/outside linebacker, and might be the perfect successor to someone like Darius Fleming, only better suited physically to play up and down in a 3-4. Ray’s another athlete that’s got plenty of size and room to fill out, and gives Paul Longo another big body to put into his workshop and turn into granite.
BRENNAN SCARLETT — DE: Here’s another target that’s got the athleticism to bring speed off the edge, but the frame to grow into a 3-4 defensive end. His offer list (USC, LSU, Oregon, Cal) gives you an idea of what type of athlete he is, and while it’s hard to say what Scarlett ends up doing, he’s another high-end prospect that could add to the wealth of prospects joining him.
Adding Ray, Niklas or Scarlett to a front seven group that includes Brad Carrico, Ben Councell, Anthony Rabasa, Tony Springmann, and Stephon Tuitt would help enhance what might already be the best haul of big-bodied defensive prospects that I can remember. Only Rabasa is under 6-foot-4, and each of them fit perfectly into the model Kelly and his defense like to build around.
SAVON HUGGINS — RB: If there’s a position on this roster and in this recruiting class that’s thin, it’s running back. Huggins represents the Irish’s best chance at landing another one after adding Cam McDaniel last week, and would be one of the elite recruits in this class if he gives his pledge to ND. Huggins has an offer list that’s as good as anybody’s and has Notre Dame on the top of his list along with home state Rutgers. If there’s a big fish out there offensively for the Irish, Huggins is it.
AMIR CARLISLE — RB: A relatively recent offer by the Irish, Carlisle is committed to Stanford but looking at the Irish this weekend. He’s friends with the Atkinson brothers and is a very intriguing running back prospect that’s a well-rounded player and a guy that will likely walk onto campus and push for playing time. It’s hard to be sure if Notre Dame got in too late, but if Carlisle is flying across the country to take a look, that’s got to mean something, right?
MILES SHULER — WR: Probably the fastest recruit that the Irish are going after, Shuler might represent the type of wide receiver that can blow the top off of a zone defense. Pair him with someone like Bennett Jackson and the Irish have a few guys that qualify as burners if they can talk the New Jersey product into coming to South Bend. At 5-foot-10, Shuler’s not the most imposing threat, but as one of the top prep sprinters in the country, he could just as easily become a cover corner on a roster thin in the secondary.
- Irish get commitment from safety Spencer Perry 0
- Greg Bryant suspension tests offensive depth chart 42
- Offseason Q&A: Georgia Tech 13
- Offseason Q&A: Texas 20
- Irish football players are academically at-risk — Just like everybody else’s 68
- KeiVarae Russell takes to social media to announce his return 59