Skip to content

BCS hysteria can wait, Notre Dame still needs to beat USC

Nov 12, 2012, 3:57 PM EDT

Curtis-McNeal-Stiffarm

With two Saturdays left in Notre Dame’s season, two highly unrealistic scenarios are close to playing out before our very eyes. First, the Irish might run the table, completing as improbable of a undefeated regular season as you can remember. Second, it might not matter, and a 12-0 Notre Dame will be held out of the national championship game.

If you were looking for a prop bet that would pay out like a super lotto ticket, you could’ve found plenty of takers back in August. That’s when Notre Dame was kept out of the preseason polls, if only because it was widely agreed that the Irish played the toughest schedule in the country, a slate that felt destined to come with four or five losses.

But a funny thing happened along the way. After months of offseason hypothesizing and turning coffee table debate into definitive, preseason rankings, eventual football games were played. And it turned out that the Irish were much better than people expected while their opponents maybe weren’t as tough. Sure, Michigan and Michigan State didn’t turn out to be top ten teams, and BYU slipped up some after a ten win season. But they definitely didn’t turn into Missouri State or North Texas, two pre-purchased victories for Kansas State. Winning ugly against BCS opponents like Purdue or Pitt isn’t going to win a fashion show, but it tells you more than scheduling Arkansas State or Tennessee Tech will, the pride of conferences Sun Belt and Ohio Valley respectively.

Yet this isn’t another column to bemoan the plight of the Fighting Irish. It’s not another wasted exercise in trying to find apples-to-apples comparisons in a college football world that will never resemble a fruit stand. Don’t get me wrong, those arguments can — and should — be made. But only after Notre Dame beats USC. Because until then, there’s really nothing to talk about.

In many ways, USC’s season is a microcosm of Notre Dame’s opponents. The Trojans started the year atop the national rankings. Armed with a golden boy quarterback, two elite wide receivers, a running back acquired via virtual free agency from Penn State, and a defense that returned eight starters (remember, that’s what matters in those summer months), it took a while for some of Southern Cal’s fatal flaws to be exposed, as they were in losses to Stanford, Arizona and Oregon.

But that’s not to say the Trojans aren’t dangerous. In many ways, having USC in the way of Irish immortality makes this team one of the most frightening of all. As Lane Kiffin learned this year, it’s quite different being the hunted rather than the hunter, a role the Trojans relished during their 10-2 2011 campaign. It’s a role they will easily adopt next Saturday, as Matt Barkley leads his teammates into the Coliseum one last time.

The Irish still need to get past Wake Forest, a team that also beat Boston College by two touchdowns. A loss to the Demon Deacons ends any championship discussions quickly, and also legitimizes any arguments being made that Notre Dame is a pretender. But if the Irish walk out of the Coliseum 12-0, they’ll have done everything asked of them, completing a schedule that may not have been Kilimanjaro, but certainly a tougher climb than the slates faced by the other title contenders.

Any championship determined by computers, pollsters and fellow coaches is bound to end up rankling a team or two, especially if more than two teams run the table. But you can hardly blame Brian Kelly for staying out of the debate, as he knows what stands between him and his shot at a national title.

Southern Cal.

A year after getting punked at home at Notre Dame Stadium, don’t expect Kelly and his staff to come up for air until they leave Los Angeles undefeated.

Then? Let the politicking begin.

Latest Posts
  1. Bryant begins Juco career, opens up recruitment

    Aug 27, 2015, 12:34 PM EDT

    Notre Dame v Syracuse Getty Images

    It appears that the Greg Bryant era at Notre Dame is over. The junior running back, who was declared academically ineligible to play for the Irish this fall, has enrolled at ASA Miami, a junior college with a new football program run by former Irish assistant Ernest Jones.

  2. Last looks: Running back

    Aug 27, 2015, 9:00 AM EDT

    Franklin American Mortgage Music City Bowl Getty Images

    After two seasons of trying to find carries for a handful of emerging running backs, Notre Dame has the opposite problem: Trying to spread out a growing workload among a smaller, highly-differentiated position group.

  3. Last looks: Defensive line

    Aug 26, 2015, 1:56 PM EDT

    North Carolina v Notre Dame Getty Images

    With the season right around the corner and preseason camp finished, it’s time to get our final preparations done before the games start counting and the journey begins. We spent the summer pumping out tens of thousands of words on Notre Dame’s evolving roster, so if you’re looking for 50 hours of easy reading, check out the Irish A-to-Z series.

  4. Now Open: Final preseason mailbag

    Aug 26, 2015, 12:42 PM EDT

    New Mailbox

    Have a final question before we have actual football to talk about? Today’s the day. Drop them below or on Twitter @KeithArnold.

  5. It’s here: Video board going into south end zone at Notre Dame

    Aug 25, 2015, 5:06 PM EDT

    Updated Notre Dame Stadium

    Notre Dame announced a number of enhancements to Notre Dame Stadium on Tuesday. Most notable among them, a video board that’ll go atop the south end zone.

  6. Irish A-to-Z: Malik Zaire

    Aug 25, 2015, 12:45 PM EDT

    Franklin American Mortgage Music City Bowl Getty Images

    Our final installment of the A-to-Z series is perhaps our most important one. Because Notre Dame’s fate is in the hands of quarterback Malik Zaire.

  7. Butler makes surprise ascent to third cornerback role

    Aug 24, 2015, 2:18 PM EDT

    Purdue v Notre Dame Purdue v Notre Dame

    With the injury to freshman cornerback Shaun Crawford, an unlikely candidate has emerged as the frontrunner for the No. 3 cornerback job: Devin Butler. The junior, who struggled mightily at times last season after he was forced into action, looked to have lost his grip on that spot this spring after strong work by sophomore Nick Watkins.

  8. Irish A-to-Z: Justin Yoon

    Aug 24, 2015, 12:27 PM EDT

    Yoon

    No freshman will be tossed into the deep end quicker than kicker Justin Yoon. Essentially Notre Dame’s sole option to kick field goals in 2015, Brian Kelly and the Irish coaching staff are putting a ton of the shoulders of a true freshman, who’ll be asked to fix a three-point operation that went haywire down the stretch after the Irish’s all-time field goal leader Kyle Brindza lost his mojo.

  9. Irish A-to-Z: Brandon Wimbush

    Aug 23, 2015, 10:45 AM EDT

    St.Peter's Prep signing day ceremony St.Peter's Prep signing day ceremony

    When Brandon Wimbush enrolled in school this summer, he became the latest blue-chip quarterback to join the Notre Dame football program with the burden of great expectations. The New Jersey state player of the year, Wimbush would be wise to forget about the prep accolades, instead focusing his efforts on learning the playbook, with the third-string quarterback closer to the field than you’d ideally want.

  10. Even without Jones, expectations clear for Gilmore’s DL

    Aug 21, 2015, 12:12 PM EDT

    Blue & Gold Illustrated Blue & Gold Illustrated

    Keith Gilmore’s move to Notre Dame reunites him with Brian VanGorder, two football lifers who have known each other since they shared a huddle as players. After a long coaching career, Gilmore also reunites with Brian Kelly, a coach he’s worked for at Grand Valley, Central Michigan, Cincinnati and now Notre Dame.

  11. Irish A-to-Z: Mykelti Williams

    Aug 21, 2015, 9:00 AM EDT

    Property of Indianapolis Star Property of Indianapolis Star

    Notre Dame landed another Indianapolis product when safety Mykelti Williams joined the Irish this summer, the freshman lending some much needed depth to the secondary. Hailing from Warren Central, the same program that brought Notre Dame Sheldon Day, Williams’ might not contribute as quickly as Day did, but he’ll have a chance to compete for a spot in the two deep behind Max Redfield at free safety.

  12. Irish A-to-Z: Dexter Williams

    Aug 20, 2015, 12:54 PM EDT

    Orlando Sentinel Orlando Sentinel

    With Notre Dame’s running back depth chart down Greg Bryant, freshman Dexter Williams has a clear line to the football field this fall. While wide receiver Justin Brent has converted to the backfield and Tarean Folston returns as a starter, Williams and fellow freshman Josh Adams couldn’t ask for a more advantageous situation, especially with C.J. Prosise taking time to heal an ailing hip flexor.

  13. Suspension behind him, Russell ready to dominate

    Aug 20, 2015, 12:17 PM EDT

    KeiVarae Russell KeiVarae Russell

    Don’t talk to KeiVarae Russell anymore about his suspension. He’s not all that interested. He discussed it with Sports Illustrated, he discussed it at the opening of training camp and he continued to answer questions about it on Media Day.

  14. Freshman CB Shaun Crawford lost for season with ACL tear

    Aug 19, 2015, 10:13 PM EDT

    Shaun Crawford, Tyree Kinnel, Andre Douglas Shaun Crawford, Tyree Kinnel, Andre Douglas

    Talented freshman cornerback Shaun Crawford tore his ACL at practice on Wednesday and is lost for the season. Brian Kelly made the announcement Wednesday night via the sports information department.

  15. Irish A-to-Z: Ashton White

    Aug 19, 2015, 1:49 PM EDT

    Rivals.com Rivals.com

    As part of a talented group of freshman defensive backs, Ashton White has made his presence felt on campus quickly, joining Shaun Crawford and Nick Coleman in their attack on the depth chart. Another cornerback with good length and athleticism, White’s career begins as the freshman class looks to make an unlikely imprint on the 2105 season.

  16. Five things we learned: Notre Dame’s Media Day

    Aug 19, 2015, 4:03 AM EDT

    It was the standard Media Day dog-and-pony show in South Bend on Tuesday, with national reporters descending on Notre Dame to pay proper respects to the Irish football program, all while likely wondering if this is indeed “the year.” And perhaps it’s because Brian Kelly already delivered a lengthy state of the union address to open camp—or more likely—because he’s already sick of talking about the enhanced expectations for his sixth team, Tuesday afternoon felt like a redundancy that coaches and players alike wanted to put in the rearview mirror.

  17. Irish A-to-Z: Nic Weishar

    Aug 18, 2015, 1:30 PM EDT

    Nic Weishar

    One of fall camp’s biggest surprises, tight end Nic Weishar has taken off his redshirt and is intent on making up for lost time. In a position battle that lacks a returning starter (or anybody with any significant experience), Weishar is making sure that the coaching staff sees him as a viable option to contribute, especially in the pass game.

  18. Irish A-to-Z: Nick Watkins

    Aug 18, 2015, 8:42 AM EDT

    South Bend Tribune / Robert Franklin South Bend Tribune / Robert Franklin

    After a freshman season swimming in the proverbial deep end, cornerback Nick Watkins enters his sophomore season with a better understanding of Brian VanGorder’s defense. And he better. Because with KeiVarae Russell and Cole Luke in front of him, Watkins’ path to the field is just as tough as it was in 2014.

  19. Irish A-to-Z: John Turner

    Aug 17, 2015, 9:55 PM EDT

    Rice v Notre Dame Getty Images

    John Turner went from the bottom of the safety depth chart to the top of the outside linebackers in a spring, one of the primary beneficiaries of the transition to defensive coordinator Brian VanGorder. And while Turner was surpassed by converted wide receiver James Onwualu, the Indianapolis native supplied key support in special teams while providing some athleticism at a position that desperately needed it.

  20. Irish A-to-Z: Andrew Trumbetti

    Aug 17, 2015, 2:11 PM EDT

    Jarron Jones, Andrew Trumbetti, Devin Gardner Jarron Jones, Andrew Trumbetti, Devin Gardner

    After enrolling early for the spring, defensive end Andrew Trumbetti nearly became Notre Dame’s first ever true freshman starter at the position. He didn’t do it, with the Irish defensive staff choosing junior Romeo Okwara to run with the first team. But it’s worth putting that quick ascent into context, the young defensive lineman both quick out of the gate and one of the only options at a position that needed reloading.