Author: Keith Arnold

Everett Golson

Notre Dame Mailbag: It’s all about the Quarterbacks


One question, asked a half-dozen different ways. And it’s all about the quarterbacks.


cajunirish: EG is currently taking a needed scholarship and IMHO has been outplayed by MZ. What are the chances EG transfers and frees up that scholarship?

bxirish162: Considering ND’s wealth @ QB -Would ND be better off starting
Zaire and getting reps to other QBs behind him? Golson’s time seems to have passed via multiple causes but passed nevertheless.

irishkevy: All this talk about Malik Zaire as the full time starter at QB makes my head hurt. Say it ain’t so, Brian Kelly & staff have officially lost their mind(s). Please tell me I’m wrong here?!?! Gearing up for the most potential on an ND roster and they’re going to start a QB who’s furthest completion will be a 3 yard pass.

notrebob: Keith,I’m a firm believer in golson,and golson alone,he has to be the starter at least lead dog,without golson ND doesn’t beat LSU I am of the group who say if you have 2QBS you have none what sir say you.

@NastraDumas: Who do you think ND’s offense will be better off with under center this season?Golson or Zaire? Why?


While the search for new coaches took up most of February, it’s hard to think of anything over these next two months that’ll take up as much time as the quarterback race. In Golson and Zaire, Brian Kelly has two quarterbacks who have won football games. (In Zaire’s case, football game.)

In 2012, Golson was a risk-averse game manager who protected the football, extended plays with his legs and made a few key big plays as he led the Irish to an undefeated regular season. In 2014, he was one of college football’s best playmakers, but his propensity for turnovers made it impossible for the Irish offense to outscore opponents down the stretch and hold on to win football games.

The love and respect for Zaire comes from a few places. One, he’s the type of football player you can’t help but love to watch. Fearless as a runner, Zaire had no problem carrying the load against LSU. As a leader, his enthusiasm—whether down by multiple touchdowns to USC or flooded with emotions after a bowl victory—is exactly what you want from a quarterback.

It’s just too hard to know exactly what Notre Dame has in Zaire. But we do know that he’s capable of moving the Irish offense on the ground and showed a decent enough touch in his limited opportunities as a thrower.

From a leadership point of view, Golson never turned into the face of the offense. His quiet nature and reserved attitude hardly shout out leader or captain. That’s a real issue moving forward, especially with Zaire being such a natural. Then again, Dayne Crist had all the leadership skills you could ever want, but didn’t have the football acumen to match.

In a perfect world, both quarterbacks stay on campus. Both quarterbacks embrace competition, pushing each other to be better in 2015. And both quarterbacks get a chance to play, compete and help Notre Dame win. It worked for Chris Leak and Tim Tebow. It can work for Golson and Zaire.

Kelly’s reluctance to hand the offense over to Zaire last year says everything you need to know in his belief that he was prepared to lead the team to victory. That just as much on Zaire as it is on Kelly, with the Irish head coach doing what he believed best for the team.

But at the same time, allowing one player to make mistake after mistake without letting his backup get a shot makes little sense. Remember the punishment for Max Redfield? It lasted even after Austin Collinsworth and Drue Tranquill struggled to cover the ground they needed out of a free safety. That’s two sets of rules for two different positions. That’s not good for a football team.

Ultimately, there are just too many variables in this battle to feel like you can have a firm grasp on the situation. They’ll start over fresh with a new quarterback coach and offensive coordinator in Mike Sanford. They’ll be learning some new concepts and evaluated differently. They’ll also have a chance to put last season in the rearview mirror, a helpful exercise for both Golson and Zaire.

I still think Golson is the quarterback who can do the most for Brian Kelly’s offense. But I’m not sure Notre Dame is committed to running that offense anymore.

Not after seeing the Irish roll through LSU in the bowl game. Not after realizing the offensive line can dictate terms and a gameplan that isn’t 100 percent quarterback reliant can take college football’s ultimate prize.

So, in short, I have no idea what will happen.

But man, this sure will be interesting to watch.

Mailbag: Now Open

New Mailbox

Against my better judgment, let’s try this again. With spring practice beginning next week, let’s open up the mailbag.

Football questions welcomed. Brevity appreciated. Trolls ignored.

Drop them below or @KeithArnold.

Tracking fifth-year spots and the bumpy road to 85 scholarships

Jarrett Grace

With Notre Dame on break, the campus is quiet one week before spring practice gets started. But the work inside the Gug is still likely underway, with recruiting efforts for the 2016 cycle pushing forward and discussions about the 2015 roster taking center stage.

While Matt Hegarty’s transfer announcement was the first big move, there are other very difficult conversations likely happening in the near future. With the 24-man recruiting class set to hit campus this June—along with graduate transfer Avery Sebastian—we will get a closer look at how Brian Kelly plans on dealing with the very first roster crunch of his tenure in South Bend.

As we look at the fifth-year senior candidates, it’ll be very interesting how the Irish coaching staff—not to mention the players who will all likely have immediate transfer opportunities after earning their degrees in May—let this play out.

There’s a chance Notre Dame could have players practicing this spring that aren’t a part of the roster come summer and fall. And that’s before taking into consideration the very likely return of KeiVarae Russell and the intention of bringing back Ishaq Williams as well.

Here are the fifth-year candidates currently on the roster:

Josh Atkinson
Jalen Brown
Amir Carlisle
Ben Councell
Matthias Farley
Everett Golson
Jarrett Grace
Conor Hanratty (Kelly already announced)
Matt Hegarty (Hegarty announced intent to transfer)
Chase Hounshell
Nick Martin
Anthony Rabasa
Joe Schmidt
Ishaq Williams


Let’s make some assumptions:

We have seen the last of Josh Atkinson and Jalen Brown. The veteran cornerback duo didn’t even travel to most away games last season and will be given every opportunity to catch on at a different program, but their time at Notre Dame is finished.

Staying on the defensive side of the ball, you can make the same assumption for Chase Hounshell. Multiple shoulder injuries took Hounshell’s career off course, and he’ll likely have to go to a smaller school to find a home.

Anthony Rabasa played a small role on last year’s defense, serving as a pass rusher in a defense in desperate need. If I were managing the roster, I’m not sure there’s room for him as a player, though what he does off the field and in the locker room (things we don’t know) could be the bigger determining factor.

On the flip side of these decisions, starters Nick Martin and Joe Schmidt are locks to return. The same for Matthias Farley and Everett Golson, with Golson holding the eject button if he feels the quarterback job won’t be his. (I don’t see this happening.)

Jarrett Grace needs to be healthy. We’ve heard Kelly nearly will him back to health with his frequent updates, but after a catastrophic injury that stayed far more under the radar than it should have, Grace seems to be back to playing shape this spring.

If he can play, he’ll be back. If not, it’ll make for a very difficult loss to the team, even if his shoes have been filled capably by Joe Schmidt on the field.

Because Amir Carlisle started the season opener in 2013 at tailback and had a successful first season as a slot receiver, he’s a good bet to return in my mind. Again, more opinion more than confirmed truth, but Carlisle is a high-character kid who can play a position of need on the roster, making him valuable.

Ben Councell might be a different story. Recovering from an ACL injury suffered in 2013 wasn’t easy . He’s also a tough fit in Brian VanGorder’s defense. We heard early last season that Councell would be a versatile piece of the Irish defense. That didn’t happen. So if he doesn’t feel like he’ll have a large role in the defense—or doesn’t feel like he can compete because of the injuries that have piled up—Councell might be on the bubble.

As Pete Sampson reported a few weeks ago, Williams needs to reapply to the university. From there, it’ll be very interesting how it all shakes out, as numbers seem to be tight. But Williams is a veteran body up front, something we saw a need for last season.

Fun With Numbers

Let’s look at how the Irish will get to 85 scholarships by the fall:


24 incoming recruits
22 second-year players
22 third-year juniors
11 seniors
graduate transfer (Avery Sebastian)
re-enrollment (KeiVarae Russell)
12 remaining fifth-year candidates
92 scholarship players

We’ve already basically subtracted four or five members from the fifth-year group if we’re to believe our assumptions. So that makes the seven subtractions look much more manageable than two or three scholarships.

And this is when we get used to the law of averages. Last year, Nile Sykes never made it to the season. From the 2013 recruiting class, we never saw Eddie Vanderdoes in South Bend and Rashad Kinlaw was dismissed as well.

Attrition hit the 2012 recruiting class even harder. Gone are Justin Ferguson, Gunner Kiel, Will Mahone, Davonte Neal and Tee Shepard.

So before we sound the alarm, there’s likely a very strong grasp on what is going on inside this program when the staff decided to expand their signing class to 24, and very good reason why Kelly sounded bullish on accepting a few graduate transfers as well.

Notre Dame doesn’t officially recognize redshirts. One of the benefits of forcing students to earn a degree in four years before being accepted into the graduate program is that it allows both the coaching staff and student-athlete to have full flexibility.

So while it certainly makes for some uncertainty as we try our best to track the roster, after five years of program building, we’re finally experiencing the first champagne roster problem of the past decade.

No change to CFB Playoff a good thing for Notre Dame

Jack Swarbrick

The only reviews of the College Football Playoff that matter are in. And after one year and a whole lot of excitement and unpredictability, don’t expect to see any changes coming soon.

That’s a good thing for Notre Dame.

And with athletic director Jack Swarbrick holding a seat at the table among the NCAA conference commissioners that orchestrated the first playoff, there’s a belief among the actual decision makers that the status quo is more than good enough.

Speaking with ESPN’s Heather Dinich, it appears the lessons learned from the near-annual tweaking of the BCS are a big reason why things are staying put.

“I think we made several mistakes with the BCS, and one of them was that, for a while, we were continually changing certain aspects of it,” ACC commissioner John Swofford told ESPN.

So for all the concerns that TCU and Baylor’s exclusion would have, Year 2 will stay four teams and the same process for the selection committee, and it’s looking like any major tweaks aren’t coming any time soon.

For a Notre Dame team that still plans on scheduling difficult games, that means they’ll still face the challenge of not playing for a conference championship. But they won’t see any radical alterations with automatic berths or tweaked formulas.

We might even get rid of the ridiculous weekly rankings that served as a mostly as debate fodder.

“That’s really the only change I would hope we have a conversation about in April,” Mountain West commissioner Craig Thompson told ESPN. “We don’t need seven. I know ESPN likes seven. It’s great ratings, but there’s other ways you get around it. It’s good information because all week you can argue back and forth … so it’s all good for the sport. But they don’t mean anything, quite honestly.”


Ohio State’s victory—beating Alabama and Oregon after leapfrogging TCU and Baylor for the fourth seed—likely kept any major changes from even being considered. But even if Year One drew the ire of the majority (it didn’t) for very good reasons, forcing the teams competing to change (goodbye Cupcakes) rather than simply tweaking the rules makes a ton of sense.

Sure, logistical moves are needed. Helping families attend games and not feel the wrath of last-minute travel and hotel rates is a no-brainer. But while switching to eight or 16 teams has been discussed more than a few times, the Pac-12’s Larry Scott was more than candid about the final decision on four.

“We spent a lot of time thinking about it. We looked at other models with more teams,” Scott told ESPN. “First and foremost, I think we don’t want to go further, in terms of the number of games the student-athletes are playing. We want to preserve the importance of bowls that are not in the playoff. We want to keep the importance of the regular season and the drama involved, and we want to keep college football a one-semester sport and not go further into January. For me, those are the four primary reasons we think four is the right number.”

After a few rocky years, annual realignment worries had some Irish fans wondering if Notre Dame was destined for a forced marriage as a full-time member of a conference. But while the Big 12 will likely try to add a conference title game and other moves are likely on the horizon, it appears the largest variable in the equation isn’t changing.

And that’s a very good thing for Notre Dame.


Spring Solutions: Defensive Line

North Carolina v Notre Dame

In a showdown with the defending national champions, most neutral party observers were shocked when Notre Dame’s defensive front dominated Florida State’s veteran offensive line.

So were most Irish fans.

With Jarron Jones breaking loose and Sheldon Day causing problems, the Irish’s two interior defensive tackles showcased their abilities. Patched together by players young and old, Brian VanGorder and Mike Elston managed to get productivity out of the defensive end spot as well.

But as the season continued and injuries hit, the critical lack of depth showed itself as Notre Dame’s front fell apart. Behind Day and Jones was little experience. An already inexperienced defensive end spot looked more and more lost as reserves playing reserves turned the final product into a group held together by string and glue.

The depth chart returns largely unchanged, with reinforcements (perhaps young and old) on their way. With new defensive line coach Keith Gilmore infusing a new voice into the meeting room, let’s take a look at the defensive line before spring practice starts next week.



DE: Andrew Trumbetti, Soph.
DT: Jarron Jones, Sr.*
DT: Sheldon Day, Sr.
DE: Isaac Rochell, Jr.
DE: Romeo Okwara
DE: Grant Blankenship, Soph.
DT: Daniel Cage, Soph.
DT: Jon Bonner, Soph.*
DT: Jay Hayes, Soph.
DT: Jacob Matuska, Jr.*
DE: Jhonny Williams, Soph.*
DT: Peter Mokwuah, Soph.*
DT: Jerry Tillery, Fr.
DT: Micah Dew-Treadway, Fr.

*Denotes fifth-year available

This group could also still add Ishaq Williams, who needs to do some academic work before reapplying to the university for summer school. Technically, it could also include Anthony Rabasa and Chase Hounshell as well, though it’s assumed that both will be moving on after graduation, either to another program or to life after football.



Andrew Trumbetti: After a solid debut season, Trumbetti needs to take the type of step forward we saw from Isaac Rochell last year. Likely, that’ll come in the weight room. But ideally, it’ll come from a speed, quickness and pass rush ability as well.

Notre Dame is desperate for a pass rusher. They’ll add Jhonny Williams and Jon Bonner into the mix this spring with Bo Wallace coming in this summer. Most think that’s not enough, but after being thrown into the mix early, Trumbetti establishing himself this spring would be key towards this defensive line stepping forward on generating heat on the quarterback.

Jarron Jones: There are still screws in Jones’ foot, meaning any on-field work this spring isn’t happening. And after this coaching staff already worked through a similar injury a few years back with Braxston Cave, it’ll be key for Jones to keep his strength and conditioning up to par while he continues his recovery.

While he’s got a fifth-year of eligibility remaining, a big senior season could set up Jones for the option to head to the NFL. But he’ll need to do his best in rehab and fitness if he’s going to hit the ground running heading into next season. We saw an offseason surgery derail Stephon Tuitt’s junior season. Let’s see if the Irish training staff learns their lesson as they deal with Jones.

Sheldon Day: After making the smart move to stay in school, Day needs to prove he can stay healthy. He’s got the confidence of his coaches. And now he’ll be working with Gilmore, who has a track record of producing NFL defensive linemen.

Day led the team in “almost” plays last year, a stat less valuable than Monopoly money. Getting through spring and supplying leadership for a young position group should be what’s most important for the veteran captain, who will likely find comfort as a more vocal leader heading into his final season.

Isaac Rochell: If you’re looking for a defensive lineman to feel good about, Rochell is your guy. Early comments from Brian Kelly last year gave us a hint that Rochell was ready to take on a bigger role. And after losing Ishaq Williams in August and Tuitt to the draft, Rochell played as well as you could have hoped coming off a mostly anonymous freshman season.

It’s hard to learn much from a Vine video, but Rochell out-quicked Sheldon Day in an agility drill. He’ll likely come into spring inching closer to 300 pounds. Big, strong, fast and agile isn’t a bad skillset. Getting more comfortable as a versatile piece on the defensive line, Rochell could be a great candidate for a next-level season.

Romeo Okwara: This is it for Okwara at Notre Dame, with a redshirt season never possible after depth problems forced him onto the field. But as Okwara enters his second season at defensive end, finding more comfort at the position will be key.

You could win a lot of money by knowing that Okwara quietly led the team in sacks last season with 4.0. That says more about Notre Dame’s struggles generating pressure on the quarterback than maybe anything Okwara may have done, but it’s a nice place to start from.

Grant Blankenship: That the big-bodied freshman stepped onto campus and played spoke to the lack of depth up front. But it also should be a credit to Blankenship’s preparations.

With a few more months in the weight room, it’ll be interesting to see what Blankenship weighs on the updated spring roster. There’s plenty of room to grow, which will only help the Texan’s versatility up front.

It’s hard to have a firm grasp on what Blankenship’s best skill is. With the length that made him an early target of Bob Diaco’s for his 3-4 system, we’ll see how Keith Gilmore plans to use another nice piece of young talent.

Daniel Cage: After being on Notre Dame’s recruiting radar for just weeks, Cage stepped in at defensive tackle and played a key role in short yardage situations, a stout player at the point of attack.

Battling through late-season injuries, spring will serve as a progress report for Cage, who will be counted on to take plenty of snaps without Jones in the mix. At his best, Cage can be the type of run-stuffer that would’ve fit in just fine in a 3-4 scheme, capable of doing more in VanGorder’s system.

But starting from scratch with a new defensive line coach, Cage will be asked to prove it this spring, likely part of the next wave of young players who need to take a big step forward if the front four is going to be considered a strength.

Jon Bonner: After jumping out early last training camp, Bonner started his career as a 269-pound outside linebacker, a position listing that may have been a pipe dream, but still is quite telling about the youngster’s athleticism.

Bonner never saw the field, keeping the redshirt on as depth issues surfaced. But capable of fighting his way into the mix this spring, it’ll be curious how Bonner looks knowing that the field is only as far away as he allows it to be.

Likely a candidate to be Day’s understudy at tackle, Bonner may also have the ability to add some pass rush to the mix.

Jay Hayes: After being thrown into the mix after injuries took hold, Hayes suffered a hard-luck injury against USC, rallying to return for the bowl game, but not an ideal development considering the thought that went into burning a year of eligibility.

But that decision was ultimately a compliment to Hayes’ ability, with the assumption that he’ll be around for five seasons one Kelly and company weren’t willing to make. That means Hayes will enter spring not just as a redshirt expecting his first taste, but rather as a veteran looking to prove something.

Keep an eye on the New York native.

Jacob Matuska: Thrown into the fire when injuries piled up, Matuska struggled with his own health and it showed late in November. A big body expected to battle in the trenches, he wasn’t able to do that successfully late in the year, with a stinger limiting him in the season’s final games.

We’ll see this spring if Matuska is an emergency depth player or a guy who can do more than that. You can’t teach nearly 6-foot-5 and 290-pounds, but that doesn’t help if you get blown off the ball. After learning what it takes to make an impact, Matuska will decide whether or not he’s a contender for a spot in the rotation.

Jhonny Williams: He looked like a bean pole when he committed to the Irish. Around a year later, Williams is hardly the former basketball and track athlete that committed to the Irish late in the process. He also could be an answer for some of the Irish’s pass rush woes.

Expect some growing pains for Williams, part of the reason he didn’t see the field last year. But he’s also capable of making an impact off the edge, making Williams’ progress worth watching.

A new voice in his ear can’t hurt with Gilmore ready to get something out of Williams. So add him to a list of intriguing redshirts ready to help.

Pete Mokwuah: One of two late defensive tackle targets by Brian VanGorder and Brian Kelly, Mokwuah committed to the Irish sight unscene, turning his back on Rutgers to join the Irish roster.

Listed at 325 pounds on the fall roster, we’ll see where Mokwuah measures in this spring. That’s a big body to work with, and one that’ll likely be transformed after nine months with Paul Longo.

Jerry Tillery: Count me among the believers in Tillery. He’s an elite athlete, and even though he’ll be learning how to grow into his frame, he’s expected to help up front, part of the reason why the transition from offensive lineman to defense appealed to the Irish coaching staff.

For as mature as Tillery is, there’s still likely an acclimatization process taking place right now. But with winter ending and spring football nearly here, Tillery will have this week’s spring break as a battery recharge before establishing his spot in the depth chart.

Micah Dew-Treadway: It’s hard to expect anything from Dew-Treadway this spring, especially after seeing where he was at the Semper Fidelis All-American game in January.

But Dew-Treadway is on campus to get a jumpstart on his career in South Bend, and the number of stars next to your recruiting ranking are all wiped out to zero regardless of who you are once you’re on campus.

He’s big enough and has intriguing game tape. We’ll see how he deals with Keith Gilmore, and likely spends these 15 practices learning the game on his way to a redshirt season.