Bradford and Benn: What could have been

46 Comments

News broke that Sam Bradford will undergo shoulder surgery by Dr. James Andrews and make himself eligible for next year’s NFL draft, ending a wonderful career at Oklahoma on a very depressing note. When Bradford turned down the chance to go in the first round of the NFL draft to return to Oklahoma, it was clear he was doing it to try and win a championship. Those plans went awry in the season’s very first game, when Bradford landed hard on his throwing shoulder after being hit hard by a blitzing BYU linebacker.

Bradford’s inclusion in the NFL draft makes him the likely first quarterback taken in the draft, but what was looking like a top heavy quarterbacking class suddenly doesn’t look as star-studded with Bradford having an injury question mark, Tim Tebow not a classic pro prospect, and Colt McCoy not playing up to his past performances.

Looking at Mel Kiper and Scouts Inc.’s big boards (imperfect, but the best thing we have), it looks like Bradford will slot in as the top quarterback, and Jake Locker will be another quarterback garnering high first round consideration. After that, it’s Colt McCoy and… Jimmy Clausen.

While Notre Dame fans don’t want to admit it, Jimmy will have a decision to make after the season. Bradford deciding to enter the draft might have done wonders for Notre Dame, as it’ll push Clausen down the draft board on the list of top quarterbacks.

Scanning teams that will be picking at the top of the draft, there really aren’t that many teams that will be looking for top-flight quarterbacks. St. Louis could be atop that list along with Washington, but all the other woeful teams look to have already made their bet on their quarterback of the future. Tampa Bay committed to Josh Freeman, Kansas City to Matt Cassel, Detroit to Matt Stafford, and Tennessee and Cleveland have to think long and hard before picking another 1st round quarterback. It might actually be a better business decision for a quarterback like Clausen to play another year in college football, and see what team picking at the top of the draft is looking to give a mega-contract to a rookie quarterback.

I don’t blame any college football player for going pro early, but I’ve got a hunch that Clausen might think about his legacy at Notre Dame a little bit more than most of the guys making the decision. And after seeing Brady Quinn tumble down the draft board, you never know what kind of flaws scouts might find in Clausen after a few months of crunching video. But if Jimmy comes back to South Bend for his senior season, Irish fans might have Sam Bradford to thank.

***

Meanwhile, watching Illinois’ season sink deeper and deeper each week, you’ve got to think wide receiver Arrelious Benn is playing the what could have been game. Derek Samson at The Sporting News had this little snippet in his Week 8 wrap-up:

Illinois WR Arrelious Benn, a Sporting News preseason first-team
All-American, caught three passes for 16 yards and did not score in the
loss to Indiana. That’s 12 straight games dating to last season that
Benn has been held out of the end zone. And if Benn returns next year,
it appears he’ll be playing for coach Ron Zook again. Illini athletic
director Ron Guenther indicated Saturday that Zook will return in 2010.

Through seven games, Benn has 25 catches for 287 yards. In 2.5 games, Michael Floyd has 358 yards and 5 touchdowns. In all likelihood, Benn will leave Illinois after the season and be drafted somewhere late in the first round, but he’s got to be kicking himself that he’s stuck playing for an offense that can’t seem to do anything right, while Golden Tate and Michael Floyd are putting up monster numbers in South Bend.

The recruiting battle for Benn was hotly contested, and got former Notre Dame quarterbacks coach Peter Vaas into some hot water after Benn leaked some of the text messages he was getting to the Washington Post. After looking back at the article, it turns out Benn would’ve been smart to listen to the former ND coach.