Army All-American bowl heavy on Irish intrigue

1 Comment

A trio of Notre Dame commitments played in the U.S. Army All-American Bowl yesterday, with defensive end Stephon Tuitt’s East team beating George Atkinson and Matt Hegarty’s West team 13-10.

Of the three Irish commitments, Tuitt probably flashed the most immediate promise, as the jumbo defensive end showed incredible power and great promise for his future in Bob Diaco’s defense. While Hegarty battled through nagging injuries to play during the game and Atkinson spent his time in the secondary instead of at wide receiver (where he’ll line up at Notre Dame), two players that are still considering the Irish stole much of the show on Saturday.

Whether Aaron Lynch ends up at Notre Dame or not, Saturday’s performance was enough to show recruitniks that this kid is the absolute real deal. With speed unnatural for a guy of his size, Lynch terrorized the West offensive line, spending much of the day in the backfield and notching 2.5 sacks. If recruiting stars are your thing, expect Lynch to get upgraded to a five-star ranking in short order.

Another Notre Dame target, Brooklyn’s Ishaq Williams, was supposed to announce his commitment during the game. But the defensive end/outside linebacker made waves for the decision he didn’t make — leaving Penn State, Syracuse and Irish fans waiting a few more days while the talented defender decides what school he’ll enroll at in before the spring semester.

“We went through the reasons that he was making this choice and the reasons didn’t quite add up to what we thought they should,” William’s father told

It seems as if Williams’ recruitment is a true three-way heat, with all schools involved feeling they have an ace in the hole. For Syracuse, home-staters feel confident that the upstart program led by Doug Marrone will land its biggest commitment since the head coach took over. Penn State has the legendary recruiter, defensive line coach Larry Johnson, Sr. on the case, helping to nullify the news that defensive coordinator, the de facto head coach, is likely leaving for a head coaching job. And the Irish have continued their dogged recruiting of Williams all the way down to San Antonio, while Irish fans cling to the hint that Williams’ father was wearing a Notre Dame hat down in San Antonio.

If Williams’ recruitment seems heated, the battle between the Irish and the Seminoles for Lynch’s signature has to be one of the best I can remember. Both coaching staffs descended on San Antonio last night, with Tony Alford taking the lead as he has throughout the entire recruiting process for Notre Dame.

After the game, Lynch shed some light on the recruiting process, including some of the internal battles he’s struggling with.

“I can be a fit anywhere I go because I’m going to work hard to do it, but I think a 4-3 defense is a better fit for me because of my speed coming on the outside,” Lynch said. “I’m more of a speed guy than a strength guy.”

While Lynch seems to have taken a familiar schematic choice as bible instead of realizing the Irish played more four-down fronts than three-man throughout the season’s final month, this quote encapsulates what a crazy time it is for a teenager trying to make a lifetime decision with the clock ticking.

“Excuse my language, but I don’t want to get bull-crapped,” Lynch said. “I want to clear up the current situation with Florida State because I want to know I can trust my coaching staff. That’s really the main issues we will talk about. I know (Florida State defensive ends) coach (D.J.) Elliot will be here today and I think (head) coach (Jimbo) Fisher, too, but I’m not sure.”

“I want to get out there and I want to play. I don’t want them to be lying to me. I want to be able to trust these people that I’m going to play for.”

Even if the Irish don’t end up with Lynch, that quote by itself is eye-popping, basically proof that somebody — likely someone inside the Florida State football program — has been telling Lynch some things that don’t quite check out, a strategy that doesn’t seem too promising when trying to talk young men into pledging their future to you.

Also consider that quote came before a reportedly eventful Saturday evening, one that saw Lynch meet with a large contingency of Florida State coaches and then meet with a large contingency of Notre Dame coaches. The meetings resulted in Lynch officially de-committing from Florida State, a move that likely means very good things for Notre Dame’s chances.

It was hard not to notice Notre Dame’s presence down in San Antonio, whether it was Atkinson, Hegarty and Tuitt on the field or the intrigue surrounding Williams and Lynch, with the spectacle ultimately much better than the actual football on the field. It’ll be an eventful final few weeks leading up to National Signing Day.